Check control responses for filtered data

Additional Info

Comparing Ratings of the Seed Stories

- How compelling do you find the evidence? The condition manipulation was least effective in the professor seed and most effective in smuggler.
- The professor seed is rated most emotional
- THe evidence distribution looks similar to suspect_committedCrime. The same hold for suspect_conviction and suspect_convictionJustified.
Comparison of Conditions (generalized over all generations)

- Questions that are condition-sensitive: author_belief, evidence, suspect_committedCrime, suspect_conviction, suspect_convictionJustified
- Questions that are not condition-sensitive: author_trust (very small), reader_emotion, story_subjectivity
Judgments over generations and conditions

- Conditions that have the same direction of development over generations:
- author_trust (decreases)
- reader_emotion (decreases – a little)
story_subjectivity (stable; no effects over generations)
- Strong evidence condition always decreases over generations, except for story_subjectivity where it is stable
Weak evidence condition is generally stable or increases, except for author_trust and reader_emotion
Interesting Observation
- Weak condition: certainty that the suspect committed the crime increases, whereas suspect_conviction stays stable –> in fifth generation, big difference between suspect_committedCrime and suspect_conviction (this effect also seems to exist in the strong condition but much less)
- Interesting correlation also to author_belief and evidence (higher uncertainty about evidence doesn’t get reflected in certainty about suspect’s guilt; author_belief shows similar distribution as evidence and suspect_committedCrime)
By Story Split

- We generally see that the suspect becomes more guilty over time in the weak condition. We don’t see that in the professor and scam story.
Split by condition

0.5 tendency

- Movements away from 0.5: author_belief weak, maybe evidence weak, reader_emotion strong and weak, suspect_committedCrime weak, suspect_convictionJustified weak


- the variance stays fairly stable over generations
Jaccard distance

- Jaccard distance increases the higher the generation, but all means are very high
Heges

- The use of hedges decreases over generations (what does it look like in a ratio with total length?)
- weak and strong condition look almost identical
Link between hedges and guiltiness of the suspect

There seems to be a small difference between conditions.